⚖️
LegalSep 4, 202614 min read

The Laws That Regulate How a Pet Is Built

On This Page▾
Gavel beside a flat-faced dog and a folded-ear cat representing breeding conformation law
Not Legal Advice

This covers breeding and welfare law across several countries, and it changes fast. Nothing here is legal advice. If you are buying, breeding, importing or showing an animal covered by any of these rules, check the current position with the relevant national authority before acting on it.

Most pet law answers one question: which species you are allowed to keep. That question is settled almost entirely by state and local law in the US, and it is the question most owners think of as "pet law."

There is a second axis, and almost nobody in the US knows it exists. It asks a different question: which shapes an animal is allowed to be. Not what species, but how it was built.

Europe has been answering that question for over a decade. The US has never answered it at all.

The Netherlands Went Furthest

Since July 1, 2014, Article 3.4 of the Dutch Animal Keepers Decree has barred anyone breeding companion animals from passing on serious hereditary defects or external characteristics that harm welfare or health. That second clause makes the shape of an animal a lawful subject of regulation.

The muzzle rule

Criteria written by Utrecht University in 2019, and formalized as a policy rule in August 2023, judge short-muzzled dogs by the craniofacial ratio: the length of the nose divided by the length of the skull. A wolf scores 1.0.

0.5 and aboveGoodNo concern on this criterion
0.3 to 0.5SufficientA breach only in combination with another listed feature
Below 0.3Extreme brachycephalyA breach on its own

Five other features count alongside the ratio, among them noisy breathing at rest, narrowed nostrils and an eyelid that cannot fully close, and a feature counts even if it has been surgically removed, so a corrected airway does not make a dog eligible to breed. There is no breed list: every dog is assessed individually.

The cat ban

On January 1, 2026 the Netherlands went further than any other country, and most reporting on the rule gets its shape wrong.

The claim you usually readWhat the decree actually says
Buying, selling, breeding and keeping are bannedOnly keeping is prohibited. A trade and import ban was drafted and deliberately dropped as redundant, on the reasoning that an animal nobody may keep is an animal nobody will buy
It bans breeding themBreeding was already unlawful from 2014 under Article 3.4. The 2026 measure adds keeping
Cats born before the cutoff are exemptCats already being kept before it are exempt, proven by microchip placement or registration date. Even the ministry's own news item gets this wrong
The exemption runs outIt does not. Exempt cats may be kept for life and may still change hands. They simply may not be shown

The decree names the TRPV4 variant behind the Scottish Fold's folded ear and presumes that any cat with forward-drooping ears carries it, so the rule can be enforced on sight. Hairlessness, the Sphynx's defining trait, means lacking a functional coat or whiskers, which leaves rex-coated breeds outside it for now. The fines are administrative: 1,500 euros for keeping a banned cat, 500 for showing an exempt one.

Fun Fact

The Dutch did cats before dogs because a folded ear is visible at three to four weeks and its mutation is not optional, while brachycephaly cannot be reliably judged until a dog is about a year old and does not cause suffering in every individual. So far there is no Dutch keeping ban for short-muzzled dogs, only the breeding restriction.

Norway Did It Through the Courts Instead

Norway has no breed-specific legislation and has never issued regulations on dog breeding, despite having the power to. What it has is section 25 of the Animal Welfare Act, which says breeding shall promote characteristics giving robust animals with good function and health, and must not pass on genes that negatively affect physical or mental function.

In 2021 the Norwegian Society for Protection of Animals sued the Norwegian Kennel Club, two breed clubs and six breeders. It was a civil declaratory action, not a prosecution, and it went the distance.

Oslo District CourtJan 31, 2022Breach, plus injunctions against named breedersBreach, plus injunctions
Borgarting Court of AppealNov 18, 2022Breach upheld, injunctions removedReversed. Not a breach
Supreme Court, 3 to 2Oct 10, 2023Breach confirmedNot a breach, conditionally

Note which breed flipped. Popular accounts often say the Cavalier ruling was overturned. It was the English Bulldog that survived, and only conditionally: the court found that grades 2 and 3 of brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome do exceed the legal threshold, but that an active breeding program with demonstrated improvement saved it. The judgment says in terms that the result may differ if that program fails to reduce severe cases, or if cesarean rates stay high.

The Cavalier finding rests on a single number: at least 15% develop syringomyelia and Chiari-like malformation solely because of breeding for exterior traits.

Two things about that ruling are routinely misreported. It is declaratory only, and no injunction survived the appeals, so nobody was ordered to stop. And the court noted expressly that outcrossing the Cavalier with other breeds would not necessarily contravene the judgment, with a pilot running in 2023 and 2024. It is not a ban on Cavalier-looking dogs. It is a ruling against continuing the current closed population.

The most consequential holding is the quietest one: section 25 can be applied at breed level, not merely animal by animal.

Germany Has the Oldest Law and the Least to Show for It

Section 11b of the German Animal Welfare Act, the Qualzucht or torture-breeding provision, prohibits breeding vertebrates where breeding knowledge gives reason to expect that offspring will hereditarily lack, or have unfit or altered, body parts or organs, with resulting pain, suffering or harm. It is forward-looking, aimed at the breeding act itself, and it covers all vertebrates and not only pets.

Breach is a regulatory offense and not a crime, carrying a fine of up to 25,000 euros, with confiscation of the animals available.

So why is Germany not the strictest jurisdiction on this list? Because the section contains no list. No traits, no breeds, no thresholds. The Act empowers a ministerial regulation to specify them, and no such regulation appears ever to have been made. What exists instead is an expert opinion from June 2, 1999 on how to interpret the section, which the Bundestag's own research service describes as an important decision aid and guideline. It binds nothing. Its own introduction concedes that implementation of section 11b had so far been unsatisfactory.

A government bill in September 2024 would have fixed exactly this, adding a list of 18 indicative symptoms including breathing difficulty, hairlessness, exophthalmos, deafness, skull malformation and body shapes making natural birth improbable, plus a display and advertising ban. It had its first reading, went to committee, and then the coalition collapsed, the Bundestag dissolved, and the bill lapsed under the principle that unfinished legislation dies with the parliament.

The clearest evidence it never passed is the statute itself: the official record still shows the last amendment as December 2022.

The Registries Move Faster Than the Governments

The single most decisive action against a breed on health grounds was taken by a cat registry, not a legislature. FIFe deleted the Scottish Fold's registration codes with effect from January 1, 2012, and its rules say they cannot be re-created. An affected cat, or any cat with one in its ancestry, cannot be registered, bred, shown or advertised, and the progeny of an affected cat cannot be registered as a British Shorthair either.

The CFA, by contrast, grants the breed championship status and disqualifies a tail lacking in flexibility due to abnormally thick vertebrae. One mutation, opposite conclusions: FIFe treats the folded ear as the disease marker, the CFA a stiff tail. FIFe is softer on hairlessness, where the Sphynx, Don Sphynx and Peterbald keep full status.

On the dog side, no kennel club has de-recognized a breed on health grounds. The Royal Kennel Club grades them instead, and nine breeds sit in Category 3, for visible health concerns linked to exaggerated conformation.

Category 3 breedsWhat the listing does
Basset Hound, Bulldog, Dogue de Bordeaux, French Bulldog, Mastiff, Neapolitan Mastiff, Pekingese, Pug, St BernardBest of Breed winners must pass a veterinary check before entering the group competition, and a check is required before a Champion title is confirmed

The Dutch Kennel Club did not stop issuing pedigrees for flat-faced breeds by choice. In June 2025 an Amsterdam court ordered it to stop issuing them without a health declaration for both parents, on penalty of 2,500 euros per improper pedigree, and the registry disagrees with the ruling.

The UK Splits Down the Middle

England licenses dog breeding and applies a condition that no dog may be kept for breeding where, on its genotype, phenotype or state of health, breeding could harm it or its offspring. Two limits matter. It binds only licensed breeders, meaning three or more litters a year or advertising a business. And cat breeding is not a licensable activity in England at all, so it does not reach cats.

The statutory guidance goes further than the regulation, telling licensing authorities that dogs which have required surgery to correct an exaggerated conformation, or which need lifelong medication, must not be bred from.

Scotland went further still. Its 2021 licensing regulations cover dogs, cats and rabbits, and both the dog and cat schedules name the word on the face of the instrument: no animal may be kept for breeding where, on its genotype, conformation, behavior or state of health, breeding could harm it or its offspring. It is the only UK provision that names conformation outright, and the only one that reaches cats.

That matters for one claim in particular. You will often read that Scottish Fold breeding is banned in Scotland under a 2020 Act. That does not appear to be right. The actual mechanism is the 2021 licensing condition, which binds licensed breeders and imposes no general ban.

Now the United States

Here is the finding: no US jurisdiction regulates breeding for conformation. Not one state. Not one city.

The evidence:

  • The only bill ever introduced was New Hampshire HB 1102-FN in 2024, which would have treated breeding or selling animals with a birth deformity that causes suffering, naming brachycephaly, as cruelty. It covered French Bulldogs, English Bulldogs, Pugs, Boxers, Boston Terriers and Persian cats. PETA described it as first-of-its-kind, which is itself the strongest confirmation that nothing comparable exists. The American Kennel Club campaigned against it. The House tabled it.
  • Over 30 states have commercial breeder laws. They cover food, water, exercise, veterinary care, space and rest between breeding cycles. A search of the full state-by-state table for congenital, hereditary, genetic defect, breeding soundness and conformation returns nothing.
  • Thirteen states preempt breed-specific local ordinances entirely, foreclosing action at city level.

Two state rules come close without reaching it. Virginia requires a commercial breeder to have a veterinarian certify annually that a female is in suitable health for breeding, and to breed her only between 18 months and 8 years. That screens the mother's condition on the day, not heritable traits. And Illinois requires licensees to release for sale only animals free of disease, injuries or abnormalities, a point-of-sale condition on the individual puppy that places no restriction on the mating.

Twenty-two states have pet purchaser protection laws, the so-called puppy lemon laws, giving buyers a refund or veterinary costs when a dog turns out to have a congenital condition.

So the American approach is consistent: it regulates the transaction in a genetically compromised animal, and the mother's condition on the day of mating. It has never regulated the mating decision itself.

By contrast, a 2023 survey found 11 of 22 European countries legislating on extreme breeding, across six distinct models: banning breeding for specific features, banning breeding of certain breeds by conformation, protecting future offspring, banning import or marketing of extreme features, banning the showing of certain breeds, and banning ownership of certain features. Flanders bans both breeding and ownership of Scottish Fold cats.

What the US Regulates Instead

American law will not touch how an animal is built, but it has a little to say about how one is altered afterward. Non-therapeutic cat declawing is banned in six states and DC, New York first in 2019 and California from January 2026, and seven California cities banned it earlier still, racing a state law that stopped cities from regulating veterinary procedures; the Los Angeles ordinance's urgency clause says so outright. Ear cropping and tail docking are banned nowhere: the nine states that regulate cropping and the three that regulate docking say only who may perform them, and the American Kennel Club's position since 2008 is that both are integral to defining and preserving breed character.

The UK goes the other way. Docking is prohibited except for certified working dogs under five days old, ear cropping has no exemption at all, and it is a separate offense to show a docked dog at an event the public pays to enter.

The Line That Says It All

American law is perfectly capable of writing a categorical ban on cosmetic body modification with no veterinary escape hatch. It has done so. Just not for dogs.

New York bans docking a horse's tail outright, and separately bans showing a docked horse. Two sections later in the same chapter, its law on dogs does nothing more than require that a veterinarian perform the cropping under anesthetic, and expressly permits importing a cropped dog for breeding purposes.

Two species, two philosophies, adjacent sections of one statute. California does the same, banning tail docking of horses and cattle with an exception only to save the animal's life or relieve its pain. Rhode Island bans it for bovines. Ohio restricted it for dairy cattle from 2018.

Livestock and horses get the categorical rule. Companion animals get a rule about who holds the scalpel.

Outside the Netherlands, the Buyer Decides

Outside the Netherlands, no law will stop anyone buying a dog that cannot breathe, and in the US no state or city regulates how a pet is built. Registry papers settle little, since one registry can bar a breed that another shows for championships on the same evidence. The BOAS grading scheme gives a buyer the airway check the law leaves undone. Every change so far, from the Norwegian ruling to the Dutch cat ban, has moved toward restriction, and nothing has moved toward permitting more.


Sources & Further Reading

Last reviewed 1 Nov 2026 · 8 sources

Also consulted

  • Rijksoverheid: keeping ban on folded-ear and hairless cats from January 1, 2026
  • RVO: what the Dutch cat keeping ban covers, including the fines
  • German Bundestag: BT-Drucksache 20/12719, the 2024 German reform bill that lapsed; research service on the status of the 1999 Qualzucht opinion
  • Royal Kennel Club: Breed Watch categories
  • Raad van Beheer: response to the June 2025 pedigree ruling
  • Rechtbank Amsterdam, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2025:3831
  • Defra statutory guidance on dog breeding licensing
  • PETA: New Hampshire HB 1102-FN, described as first-of-its-kind
  • American Kennel Club: legislative alert opposing New Hampshire HB 1102; statement on ear cropping and tail docking
  • Eurogroup for Animals: extreme breeding in Europe, mapping of legislation
  • New York Agriculture and Markets Law: consolidated cruelty statutes
  • California Penal Code section 597n: docking of horses and cattle
  • Los Angeles declawing ordinance, with its urgency clause
  • California AB 867 (2025): the state declawing ban

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it illegal to own a Sphynx or a Scottish Fold now?

In the Netherlands, since January 1, 2026, yes, but only keeping is banned. A trade and import ban was drafted and dropped as redundant, and breeding had been unlawful there since 2014 under a separate provision. The exemption covers cats already kept before the cutoff, proven by the microchip date, and not cats merely born before it. Those cats may be kept for life and may still change hands.

Does any US state ban breeding flat-faced dogs?

No, not one state or city. The only bill ever introduced, New Hampshire HB 1102-FN in 2024, would have treated breeding animals with a birth deformity that causes suffering as cruelty; the American Kennel Club campaigned against it and the House tabled it. Over 30 states have commercial breeder laws, and none of them reach conformation or heritable disease.

Did Norway ban the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel?

Not exactly. In October 2023 the Supreme Court held that breeding the Cavalier as currently practiced breaches section 25 of the Animal Welfare Act, since at least 15% develop syringomyelia and Chiari-like malformation from breeding for looks. The case was civil and declaratory, no injunction survived, and the court said an outcrossing project would not necessarily breach the judgment.

Why do two cat registries disagree so completely about the Scottish Fold?

Because they read the same mutation and drew opposite conclusions. FIFe deleted the breed's registration codes from January 1, 2012, and bars affected cats and their descendants from registration, breeding and showing. The CFA keeps the breed in championship competition and disqualifies a stiff tail caused by abnormally thick vertebrae instead. One registry treats the folded ear as the disease marker, the other the tail.

Can I still show a dog with cropped ears in the US?

Yes. The American Kennel Club holds that ear cropping, tail docking and dewclaw removal are acceptable practices that help define breed character, and no AKC breed standard disqualifies a natural ear or tail. The UK goes the other way: showing a docked dog at an event the public pays to enter is a separate offense there.

What does the US regulate, if not breeding?

Elective surgery, and only partially. Six states and the District of Columbia now ban non-therapeutic cat declawing, most recently California with effect from January 1, 2026. But no state law prohibits ear cropping or tail docking of dogs at all. Every US restriction on those is a rule about who may perform the procedure, not whether it may be done.

Dex, a bearded dragon, lying in long grass with his mouth open in the sun

Written by Michael Ryan

Mike keeps two rescued bearded dragons, Dex and Cera, and writes the care guides on BeastlyFacts from his own research and mistakes. He is not a veterinarian.

More about Michael Ryan →

You May Also Like

Subscribe - it's free

An occasional email when something new is worth your time. No spam.

Loading...